Italy in crisis – there but for First Past the Post go we ….

italian flagItaly is in crisis with a hung bicameral parliament after recent elections. The Dow Jones is down; the Euro is falling; the world holds its breath while the third largest economy in Europe faces a period of uncertainty while politicians horse trade for a coalition deal.

BALLOTIf the UK Liberals had their way, we might be facing this crisis in perpetuity as the Italians have.  Part of the coalition deal following the election of a UK hung parliament for the first time in many years was to allow the Liberals to promote a switch to a proportional voting (PR) system for the parliamentary elections in this country.  They went for a half way house called the Alternative Vote (AV) system, rather than the full PR for which this minority party has always craved on the basis it would make them the permanent king-makers, flip-flopping between the two main UK parties to hold the balance of power.  It was understood that the Conservative part of the coalition would oppose this and, thank goodness, the country voted against it overwhelmingly.

Poor old Italy, like most European countries, has endured one form or another of PR voting for a very long time and, as a consequence, it has a endured a patchwork of coalitions.  Now they are likely to have another one with the Italian lower house (the Chamber of Deputies with 630 members) showing the slenderest majority for the left while the upper house (the Senate with 315 members) seems to have secured the tiniest majority for the right.  The result is deadlock because Italy’s bicameral system gives equal weight to each house  with legislation having to be approved by both houses before it becomes law.  The result in Italy is the sort of shambles we have come to see here with the Liberals able to block some of the much needed reforms the Conservatives would put through.  We also see it in the USA with President Obama thankfully unable to borrow and spend as freely as Brown and Blair did because of the Republican majority in the House of Representatives.

Coming back to Italy, their voting system is based on party lists, just like the system we have to endure in the EU elections.  The political parties put forward their candidates in a prioritised list and the electors can only vote for the party not for individual candidates.  In this way, unpopular but powerful politicians can ensure their continued election despite their record with the voting public.

The UK Liberals are struggling at the moment with accusations flying about Lord Rennard, a Liberal peer almost unknown outside political circles but widely lauded by the Liberal cognoscenti as the primary architect of their famed electioneering style.  The Liberals are a fascinating party, combining as they do a whole range of completely contradictory qualities:

  • bastions of equality for women, gays and ethnic minorities, allegations against Lord Rennard and their apparent handling to date suggest there could be dual standards in this party of the moral high ground;
  • masters of electioneering, able to mass huge numbers of activists at election time and able to promise something different on every street corner, they have found it very hard to sit in government where people might reasonably expect them to have identifiable and coherent policies and to deliver on them;
  • in the Eastleigh by-election, the Liberals have been campaigning against house building on green fields while the local Liberal council has voted through a massive house building programme on green fields;
  • this most pro-European of parties works to attract disaffected voters from the parties of the left and right , many of whom are strongly anti-Euro federalism but who don’t realise the Liberals would support an ever closer EU – a fact the Liberals are extremely eager to conceal;
  • this Liberal party of the high ground, so able to express moral indignation and to promote equality and fairness has a reputation among Conservatives and Socialists alike for conducting the dirtiest election campaigns imaginable a characteristic for which Lord Rennard apparently deserves much credit!

It’s a funny old world.  I can’t wait to see what the electors of Eastleigh do on Thursday!

About Keith R Mitchell CBE

Qualified as a Chartered Accountant in 1967. Pursued a successful career in financial training and publishing until selling his interests in 1990. Elected a County Councillor for the Bloxham Division in 1989. Leader of Oxfordshire County Council 5 November 2001 to 15 May 2012. Chairman of the South East England Regional Planning Committee July 2002 to July 2005. Chairman of the South East England Regional Assembly July 2005 to July 2008. In HM the Queen’s 2007 Birthday Honours, appointed a Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire in recognition of services to local government.
This entry was posted in Politics and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Italy in crisis – there but for First Past the Post go we ….

  1. Trevor Craig says:

    Other countries do OK with PR, Germany being the most obvious example, just having one country with poor elections doesn’t win the argument for FPTP, its more to do with the corrupt nature of Italian politics I would imagine. The strength of FPTP is its supposed to deliver strong government and a clear result. We didn’t get that in 2010 and its looking increasingly likely that we’ll get something similar in 2015 so it doesn’t even do the job its supposed to anyway. If politicians really wanted to make things better and get the voting rate up they would all have open primaries to get better candidates who are selected on merit, a cap on party spending (both by rich non-doms and the unions) this would actually encourage people to engage with politics again rather than have to put up with the bunch of useless porn watching, second home flipping, don’t attend the debates but just turn up to vote and vote the way of the party ideological idiots in Westminster. The best part about FPTP is the clear link between MP and the area they represent, I have the system we have for voting for EU candidates, nobody knows who their candidates are and I have emailed all of mine in the past, they don’t reply to polite emails. The ideal I suppose would be the Lords having a hybrid PR system and the commons sticking with FPTP. The parties as always will be relied upon to act in their own interests rather than that of the electorate so we’re probably stuck with what we have for a while yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s